Note: This was an old post on the original “The Demented Ferrets” site, and prior to that it belonged to my personal blog. It is being placed here because this is now where it belongs. Some additional content has now been added as well.
Please don’t forget to follow the blog. You can check out our platforms for great content too!
When fans of a series gather to form large social groups over a specific type of media, we call this a fandom. In general, fandom tends to be a positive space, but there can be occasions when it isn’t. Discussions can get heated and when fandom takes a a nosedive into negativity people tend to slip off and form smaller cliques.
One of the ways this can happen is when a fandom is overrun with the “one true pairing” fallacy. This occurs when fans collectively agree that two characters belong together romantically, no matter the circumstances, or the outlying opinions of others. I’ve seen this problem occur mostly within anime and gaming, but I’m sure it happens elsewhere too. It’s a rare problem, but it is nearly toxic to a fandom when it does occur.
Now, many people have personal “OTP’s” or a “one true pairing” that they love to sail as a ship. On its own, that’s completely fine. There is nothing wrong with that. As long as the “one true pairing” isn’t forced on others as the only ship to sail, there is no problem at all with having them.
This problem of the “one true pairing fallacy” comes along when a large contingent of the fan base adopts the “one true paring” mindset viciously. This usually happens in less popular media and welled established, fan communities.
A lack of widespread diversity can hinder a fan base. Eventually, that will cause these echo chambers to exist. Particularly in older fandom, where diehard fans have lingered around for years after the initial hype ended.
A fan simply has to love and enjoy the medium. Weather or not they sail any ship should be up to them. The “one true pairing” ideology shouldn’t need to apply.
I personally never wanted to sail an “OTP”, primarily because I don’t consume media that would require me to have one. I don’t believe having an “OTP” does me any good. I don’t gain anything from the media I care about by having one. In fact, I often think it does a media like anime a huge disservice by having an “OTP”.
Anime has a tenancy to leave an open ending. Several of them are just long running advertisements for its manga counter part. To see the full story you’d have to consume both pieces of media, and some fans like myself don’t have the desire to do both.
At the end of the day, “one true pairings” can be very powerful things inside of a fandom, and its our job as fans to recognize that. We need to be respectful of the ships we sail, and she ships of others. It’s the only way to keep a fan base growing, and all fans should want that. The stronger and more diverse a fan base is, the more fan based content will thrive.
Do you sail an “OTP”? Let me know in the comments below. This has been Kernook from The Demented Ferrets…
To Our Supporters: Thank You!
With your contributions, you make our efforts possible. Thank you for supporting our content.
At the time of this post there are 3 notable contributors.
Demented Minions: Francis Murphy, Josh Sayer, and Andrew Wheal.
If You Enjoyed This Content…
|Twitch||Live streams||Tuesday: 9:00 PM – 12 AM (GMT)|
Wednesday: 9:00 PM – 12:00 AM (GMT)
Saturday: 12:00 PM – 3:00 PM (GMT)
|YouTube||Anime/Game/Movie reviews. Deep dives/analysis of RWBY.||Videos upload Monday, Wednesday, and Friday at 12:00 PM (GMT)|
|Announcements, Random tweets||Whenever a live stream begins or content releases. Doesn’t have a set schedule.|
|Our Blog||All kinds of written media including anime, games, RWBY and more.||Posts are published every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday at 12:00 PM (GMT)|
There are plenty of ways to support us. To find out more, click the button below.